Fancy Farmer Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing Fancy Farmer, a delightful gem nestled in Sharon Springs, NY, where the essence of New American cuisine shines through. This newly renovated restaurant and bar boasts a rustic barnhouse vibe, perfect for gathering with friends and family. The menu features a variety of hearty offerings, including fresh 8 oz burgers with classic fixings, fried haddock served with coleslaw, and Asiago-stuffed gnocchi in a creamy vodka sauce.
Highlights include the South Of The Border Bowl, loaded with beef barbacoa, black beans, and guacamole, giving you a taste of the Southwest. Diners rave about the juicy ribs and perfectly cooked scallops, while gluten-free and kids' options ensure everyone in your party finds something to love. With an attentive staff and a warm atmosphere, Fancy Farmer promises an exceptional dining experience you won't want to miss. Come for the food, stay for the vibes!
Burgers
Hamburger
Cheeseburger
Bacon Cheeseburger
Bourbon BBQ Cheeseburger
Chicken Breast Sandwich
Grilled or fried with your choice of Swiss, American or Cheddar cheese. Served with fries and coleslaw
Burgers
Fresh prime 8 oz burgers are cooked medium unless otherwise specified. Includes lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles and french fries
Fried Haddock
Served with French fries and coleslaw
Gnocchi / Caesar Salad Combo
Asiago Cheese stuffed Gnocchi in a vodka cream sauce served alongside a Caesar Salad.
Lite Fare
Bowls
South Of The Border Bowl
Rice, black beans, beef barbacoa, guacamole, shredded cheese, lettuce, tomato salsa and sour cream. Option: Substitute Chicken for beef barbacoa.
Chicken Wings
8 mild, hot, garlic lover's or Alabama White sauce
Loaded Pub Fries
Topped with bacon, cheese, sour cream and scallions
Coconut Shrimp
5 jumbo coconut shrimp with orange-cranberry chili sauce for dipping
Sweet Potato French Fries With Melba Sauce
Loaded Potato Skins
Pretzel Sticks With Beer Cheese
Maple Bacon Brussels Sprouts
Fried Squash Blossoms
lightly battered with basil pesto and marinara sauce for dipping.
Appetizers
Plates
Pierogies And Sausage
Grilled smoked kielbasa with 5 of our own cheese and potato pierogies smothered in butter, fried onions and sauerkraut
Hats Carbonara
Fancy Chicken
Pounded chicken breast pan-sauteed in white wine with cream
Seared Scallops
6 colossal scallops on a bed of garlic greens. These aren't the little ones! GF
Ribeye
16 oz ribeye grilled to your satisfaction We proudly serve certified prime grade beef for superior marbling and delicious flavor GF
Beef Pot Roast
Fork tender beef with our rich house-made gravy. So good! GF
Sirloin Au Poivre
10 oz sirloin with cracked peppercorns in a cognac cream sauce. GF
Redneck Surf & Turf
a third rack of our bourbon BBQ ribs with 4 jumbo fried shrimp and a lemon aioli dipping sauce. Served with coleslaw
Uptown Surf & Turf
A 10-12 oz ribeye with (4) pan-seared colossal scallops on garlic greens GF
Fancy Farmer House Salad
Mixed greens, red onion, tomatoes, cheddar cheese, mandarin oranges and candied walnuts